On You Deserve More Than a Coffee Date: Effort in a Nonchalant Dating World
Dating today often feels oddly low stakes. Coffee dates, casual plans, and an unspoken rule that putting in effort means you “care too much” have somehow become the norm. Somewhere along the way, we decided it wasn’t cool to try.
But for many people, this style of dating doesn’t feel freeing. It feels confusing, disconnecting, and quietly painful. In this post, we’ll explore how nonchalant dating culture developed, what it costs us emotionally, and why effort isn’t the same thing as doing too much.
Why Dating Feels So Low Stakes Right Now
I’ve felt it. You match, you chat, you meet for coffee, have a mid-conversation, you part ways, and everyone pretends they’re totally fine with how disposable it all feels.
A lot of people walk away from early dating experiences feeling unseen, confused, or quietly questioning their worth. Underneath that is a bigger conversation about effort, connection, and what we’re actually communicating when we keep things “chill.”
Because if we’re being honest, most of us just want to feel valued and understood. And that gets complicated fast when vulnerability feels risky, masculinity has rules, and rejection feels personal.
The Rise of Nonchalant Dating culture
Nonchalant dating didn’t come out of nowhere.
Dating apps reward efficiency, quick decisions, and emotional low-risk behavior. The coffee date has become the universal first move. It’s easy, inexpensive, and doesn’t ask much of anyone.
From a relational lens, this limits how much we really show up with each other. There’s less room for curiosity, playfulness, and genuine presence.
When dating becomes a formula, everyone stays emotionally guarded. And while guardrails feel safe, they don’t actually help us connect.
Effort Is Not the Same as Over-Investment
I’ve heard the argument: Why invest time or money if you don’t even know if you’ll click? Fair enough.
But effort isn’t about locking anything in. It’s about signaling interest and care.
What Effort Actually Communicates
Somewhere we picked up the idea that effort has to be big or expensive. Most women I know aren’t asking for that. We’re asking to feel considered.
Effort can be low-cost and high heart. A thoughtful plan. A little creativity. Showing that you paid attention.
From a relational perspective, effort opens the door to real connection. It says, “I’m here, I’m curious, and I’m willing to show up.”
When effort is missing, the message often lands as indifference. And no one wants to feel like a placeholder.
Masculinity, Vulnerability, and Emotional Risk
Men are navigating a confusing maze. Be confident, but not needy. Try, but not too hard. Be emotionally open, but also be a provider. No pressure.
For many men, early dating doesn’t feel emotionally safe—it’s too risky to be vulnerable at the outset. Dating can start to feel like performing a role instead of being a person.
Why Nonchalance Becomes Emotional Armor
Showing effort requires emotional risk. It means tolerating uncertainty and the possibility of rejection instead of defaulting to detachment.
When vulnerability doesn’t feel safe, nonchalance becomes armor.
“If I don’t care, I can’t get hurt.”
It makes sense — and it also blocks real connection.
Why Relational Therapy Can Change How Dating Feels
Here’s the part we don’t talk about enough: most of us were never taught how to do relationships.
Relational therapy isn’t about fixing you or giving dating rules. It’s about slowing down and noticing how you show up with other people.
Learning to Show Up Without Over-Performing
In a relational therapy space, effort, boundaries, and vulnerability can be explored safely. Relational therapy helps explore attachment patterns and emotional availability in dating. You get to practice showing up differently without being punished for it.
In therapy you learn how to:
stay present when things feel uncomfortable
name what you want
stay connected without over-performing or shutting down
Over time, this changes how dating feels.
You can stop playing it cool when you don’t want to. You can start showing up as yourself, with intention.
start dating with more authenticity & intention
If this resonates, you’re not broken — and you’re not asking for too much. Relational therapy can help you explore how you show up in dating, combat dating burnout, build connection without over-performing, and practice vulnerability in a way that feels safe.
Sign up for a free information session for therapy to help with dating and get started now!
Featured therapist author:
Madison Segarra is a Graduate Student Trainee Therapist who’s passionate about love, intimacy, and what it means to be fully yourself. As a former sex worker, she believes in meeting people exactly where they are and creating therapy spaces that feel safe, open, and real. Madison brings brings a little edge and a lot of heart into her work and believes that healing doesn’t have to be cold or clinical; it can be messy, human, and a little magical.
GET HELP NOW
If you are interested in therapy with Kindman & Co. and would like to learn more about the services we have to help you, follow these quick & easy steps:
Schedule a free 20-minute phone consultation with our Care Coordinator.
Get matched with the therapist who’s right for you.
Start feeling more supported and fulfilled in your life and relationships!
THERAPY AT KINDMAN & CO.
We are here for your diverse L.A. counseling needs. Our team of therapists provides lgbtqia+ affirmative therapy, couples therapy & premarital counseling, grief & loss counseling, group therapy, and more. We have specialists in trauma, women's issues, depression & anxiety, substance use, mindfulness & embodiment, and support for creatives. For therapists and practice owners, we also provide consultation and supervision services! We look forward to welcoming you for therapy in Highland Park and online.