On The Cost of Having It All: Why Every Meaningful Relationship Requires Tradeoffs
In my previous posts, I’ve explored effort in dating and the importance of remaining curious about one another. We talked about nonchalant dating culture, emotional risk, and what happens when we stop being curious about men’s experiences.
As I’ve continued thinking about modern dating, I keep returning to a different question:
What does it cost to get what we want?
It’s a question we rarely ask.
Instead, we’re often sold a much more appealing story.
That we can have it all.
The dream career, partner, family.
The dream home, body, lifestyle.
The dream freedom and fulfillment.
And while I appreciate the optimism behind that vision, I sometimes wonder if it leaves us unprepared for one of life’s most fundamental realities:
Every meaningful choice costs something.
every yes is also a no
One of the things I have come to believe as a therapist is that every choice opens certain doors while simultaneously closing others.
Not because life is unfair.
Not because we’re being punished.
Because life is finite.
We have finite time.
Finite energy.
Finite attention.
Finite opportunities.
To choose one path is, by definition, to leave another unexplored.
The physician who spends a decade training gains expertise, purpose, and the opportunity to change lives. The cost may be years spent studying while peers are dating, traveling, building families, or establishing roots.
The entrepreneur gains autonomy, creativity, and ownership. The cost may be uncertainty, stress, and relationships that receive less attention during periods of growth.
The stay-at-home parent gains time, presence, and closeness with their children. The cost may be financial dependence, career advancement, or professional identity.
The person who prioritizes relationships may sacrifice certain professional opportunities.
The person who prioritizes achievement may sacrifice certain relational opportunities.
None of these choices are wrong.
They are simply different.
Yet we often focus on what our choices give us while resisting conversations about what they ask from us.
The Myth of Having Unlimited Options
Modern dating exists within a culture that increasingly celebrates optionality.
Keep your options open.
Don’t settle.
There’s always someone better.
You deserve everything you want.
At first glance, these messages seem empowering.
But there is a hidden consequence.
If every door must remain open, eventually we stop walking through any of them.
Commitment Requires Closing Other Doors
Commitment requires exclusion.
Choosing one thing means choosing against another.
Relationships require this.
Careers require this.
Families require this.
Life requires this.
The challenge isn’t that we have choices.
The challenge is that many of us struggle to accept the reality that choices inevitably come with loss.
Modern Love, Partnership, and Practicality
Throughout history and across cultures, people have approached relationships differently.
In many modern Western cultures, we place tremendous emphasis on love, chemistry, emotional connection, attraction, compatibility, friendship, and personal fulfillment.
We want our partner to be everything—our lover, best friend, emotional support, co-parent, intellectual equal, travel companion, and life partner.
While, that is a beautiful vision, it’s also a relatively ambitious one.
Historically, and in many cultures around the world, relationships have often balanced love alongside practical considerations such as family stability, shared values, community ties, religion, economics, and long-term partnership.
This isn’t an argument that one approach is superior.
It’s simply worth noticing how much we ask modern relationships to provide.
Perhaps some of our frustration comes from trying to hold two competing desires simultaneously.
We want complete freedom to choose.
We also want certainty that we’ve chosen correctly.
We want limitless possibilities.
We also want lasting commitment.
We want love to feel effortless.
We also want it to satisfy nearly every practical need in our lives.
choosing is not settling
One of the fears that often emerges in conversations like this is the fear of settling.
But I think we’ve confused settling with choosing.
Settling says:
“I wanted more but accepted less.”
Choosing says:
“I know what matters most and I’m willing to let other things go.”
These are not the same thing.
Every meaningful life requires choosing.
Not because we failed to get everything.
Because no one gets everything.
The happiest people I know are not the people who avoided tradeoffs.
They’re the people who consciously accepted them.
grieving the lives we don’t live
What often goes unspoken is that every choice carries a small grief.
The career we didn’t pursue.
The city we didn’t move to.
The relationship we didn’t choose.
The family structure we didn’t build.
The version of ourselves we never became.
Sometimes our suffering comes not from making the wrong choice but from refusing to acknowledge that another path was left behind.
Maturity isn’t eliminating tradeoffs.
It’s learning to live alongside them.
What Are You Willing to Trade for the Life You Want?
Perhaps the question isn’t whether we can have it all.
Perhaps the question is what we’re willing to trade for the life we want.
Because every path offers something.
And, every path has a price.
The challenge isn’t avoiding tradeoffs.
The challenge is choosing the tradeoffs we can live with.
And maybe that’s true in dating more than anywhere else.
Love has never been about getting everything.
It has always been about deciding what matters most.
And choosing it with intention.
Continue the conversation.
If this resonated with you, you may also enjoy my essays on emotional effort in dating, curiosity in relationships, and why nonchalant dating culture often leaves us feeling disconnected.
Struggling to make a big relationship decision?
Whether you're deciding to commit, questioning a relationship, or trying to reconcile competing priorities, therapy can provide space to clarify what matters most. You don't have to navigate life's biggest choices alone.
Featured therapist author:
Madison Segarra, Graduate Student Trainee Therapist
Madison is passionate about helping people make sense of their experiences and find meaning in the stories they carry.
She brings a blend of curiosity, authenticity, and heart to her work and is drawn to conversations about identity, relationships, healing, and personal growth. Madison believes that transformation rarely happens in a straight line—it is often messy, deeply human, and sometimes a little magical.
Take Your Next Step Toward Support
If you’re navigating heavy relationship patterns, feeling the pressure to perform, or ready to unpack generational cycles, you don’t have to do it alone.
At Kindman & Co., we make starting therapy simple:
Schedule a Match Call: Book a free 20-minute chat with our California Care Coordinator.
Get Paired: We intentionally match you with the right relational therapist for your unique story.
Begin Healing: Start feeling more grounded, supported, and fulfilled in your life and relationships.
Holistic Individual & Couples Therapy in Los Angeles
Kindman & Co. is a human-first, identity-affirming group practice located in the heart of Highland Park (90042).
We provide specialized individual therapy, couples therapy, and premarital counseling to clients in Northeast Los Angeles—including Pasadena, Eagle Rock, and Glassell Park—as well as online throughout California.
Whether you are seeking LGBTQIA+ affirmative therapy, trauma support, or looking to navigate women's issues and creative blocks, our team of warm and welcoming L.A. therapists is here to welcome you.
