On Self-Help’s Shortcomings: Why Self-Optimization Can't Heal What Hurts
Walk into any bookstore and you'll find entire sections devoted to self-improvement. From productivity hacks and morning routines to mindset coaching and manifestation practices, the Self-Help industry promises that with the right framework, you can become happier, healthier, wealthier, or more fulfilled.
Yet many people find themselves consuming more and more self-help content, while feeling increasingly disconnected from themselves. If all of these answers are supposed to work, why do so many of us still feel stuck (and so alone)?
The problem may not be a lack of effort. It may be some of the assumptions that self-help culture asks us to accept in the first place.
The Illusion of the Self-Help Industry
I often think about the insatiable pull of information as a means of solving our problems and bettering ourselves. The pressure to ‘better ourselves’ is certainly worth exploring, but will remain a blog post for another time!
We are compelled to search for answers and seek to find ways of conjuring that lovely ‘aha!’ feeling by reading/seeing/hearing something that seems to fit. The Self-Help genre brings in billions of dollars every year because it can so reliably help us get this feeling.
“The self-help industry runs on a specific assumption: that you are incomplete. That there is a gap between who you are and who you should be, and that closing it requires the right book, the right system, the right supplements, or the right guru.” (Richard Banfield’s The Self-Help Industrial Complex is Making Things Worse)
Often boiling down to ‘it’s not you, it’s your mindset’ and insisting that by sticking to a certain framework, one can achieve exactly what they want. But it’s in that moment, when you feel like you’ve got something new to try and feel a beautiful ‘aha!’, that you’ve already been given what you wanted. Rather I should say, what you thought you wanted.
Why Self-Help Mindset Frameworks Often Fall Short
Everything that follows—applying the framework and how well it works for you—is really out of your hands.
It will depend on myriad factors that cannot be accounted for in advance and won’t always become apparent to you until conditions have changed. The author will often point to this unpredictability and offer their framework as a tool to navigate uncertainty:
That’s fine! Navigating uncertainty is what we are always doing and will always be doing for the rest of our lives.
But the frameworks often come up short because they flatten the very complexity they claim to accommodate for by implicitly taking Western psychological/philosophical beliefs as universal truths.
Deconstructing the Assumptions of Toxic Self-Help Culture
Some Self-Help Assumptions Worth Questioning
Let’s start with the most obvious assumption because it’s right there in the genre title: the idea that we exist as singular, individual, immutable selves.
Nietzsche pointed this out over a century ago when he noted how the language we use conditions our reality and its possibilities. His famous example of this, from On The Genealogy Of Morals, is how a statement like ‘the lightning flashes’ separates the ‘doer from the deed’. It implies that lightning is a thing on its own that performs the action of flashing instead of lightning being the flash itself.
Now apply this logic to our conception of ‘self’ and the way language fabricates a chain of causality that isn’t actually there.
The Myth of the Individualized Self
Self-Help books immediately assume that we are all on the same page about an immutable self being a fundamental building block of reality. This assumes you exist as a singular entity who navigates a neutral substrate dotted with obstacles and other ‘selves’ to engage with however you see fit. This aligns with how we’re encouraged to see the world not just through everyday language but through the systems that govern our culture and society.
You may be influenced by your upbringing, environment, and economic status, but at the end of the day, you alone are blamed for your struggles.
Toxic Shame and the Pressures of Optimization
The authors of these books provide nihilist frameworks to optimize your time and improve yourself in measurable increments.
It all makes sense on paper, the math checks out, and you’ve been given the tools to make real progress. You can listen to the author’s advice or you can ignore it, but you can no longer say you haven’t been told.
In a society that runs on toxic shame and relies on emotional pain like a hammer and chisel to sculpt its adherents, this is devastating.
It worked for the author! And they’ve provided examples of successful entrepreneurs, celebrities, experts who it worked for as well!
If it isn’t working for you, you only have yourself to blame.
Overcoming Our Internal Universe and Self-Flagellation
Furthermore, we are sometimes encouraged to see our own resistance to making changes we believe to be good for us as the result of parts of us that are no good.
We have our demons, our vices, our base pleasures that want us to be “lazy” or “greedy” or wrathful. These parts of us are not to be trusted and should never be listened to.
We deploy the methods that molded us against our own internal universe and have to carry the weight of all we are hiding; all that can never be allowed to meet the eyes of others lest we be injured or abandoned.
Why Emotions Aren't the Enemy of Mental Health
Here is another assumption: Human beings may not be innately rational, but acting as such is crucial to a healthy mind.
We have valorized the steady individual, who is reliable and consistently unyielding to emotional outbursts and reactions. The ‘strong silent type’.
We see emotions as irrational because we are actively encouraged to separate from and ignore our embodied experiences from a young age.
How We Learn to Suppress Our Bodily Responses
The classroom is where we learn, it is where all that is of use is reached through memorized facts or logical reasoning.
We are made to sit in rigid desks for extended periods, called out when we look out the window, required to ask permission to use the bathroom.
When I was a child the idea of having fidget toys at my desk was wholly unacceptable. My natural tendency to regulate my nervous system and maintain focus was twisted into my “being selfish” and inconsiderate to those around me.
Shame and threat of social exclusion was leveraged to make me ‘behave.’
Translating the Foreign Language of Our Sensations
Our emotional and bodily drives are not inherently irrational, we are just forced to neglect them to the point that embodied sensations might as well be foreign languages.
Hearing them here-and-there, without ever listening, will lead them to forever register as seemingly random sounds or connections to things they have no business being connected to.
The felt dissonance is to be hand-waved away or medicated to the point of numbness.
Self-Help Culture and the False Divide Between Mind and Body
And here is the final assumption I’ll address: the false dichotomy of mind and body.
Any Self-Help book that relies on ‘tricking’ the body, gamifies your bodies reactions through reward and punishment based conditioning, or demands you optimize variables the way one would a machine, has thoroughly lost the plot.
Dehumanization and the Myth of the "Meat Suit"
By painting a picture of yourself as a squishy wrinkly blob piloting a suit of meat and bone you are actively dehumanizing…yourself! You experience the cycle of abuse from both vantage points, you feel the constant anxious wrestling for control and you feel the constant debilitating pain of being harmed.
You are your body, all of it.
Moving Toward Somatic Healing and Complexity
So, Where Do We Go From Here?
I believe moving away from rigid rationality and evidence-based strategies is a great start. But where are we moving to?
The answer is really only going to arrive when we let ourselves be where we are right now.
Allow some space for your internal discomforts and tend to them as you would a child not yet able to vocalize their needs.
Embracing Contradiction and Inner Multitudes
When babies and toddlers can’t articulate what they are experiencing, we start by compassionately acknowledging their suffering. “I know, I know. I’m here. It’s okay.” is the oft-repeated phrase.
Offer this to yourself and see what comes up when you allow yourself to feel what is there.
Embrace the apparent contradictions and resist the urge to downplay certain experiences over others.
Embracing complexity means sitting with paradox and contradiction. Notice where those contradictions arise and let yourself be curious about them.
Take a break from the constant search for information and remember how much you truly already know. I’ll leave you with the classic Walt Whitman line from Song of Myself:
“Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes)”
Healing Through Connection, Not Self-Improvement
Perhaps the alternative to Self-Help is not another framework, but a different relationship with ourselves altogether? One rooted in embodied awareness rather than optimization, and connection rather than self-sufficiency.
Our emotions, sensations, and contradictions are not obstacles to overcome but invitations to understand ourselves more deeply. And while self-help culture often tells us to “figure it out alone,” healing frequently emerges through relationship: in being witnessed, understood, challenged, and cared for by others.
We were never meant to carry the full weight of being human by ourselves.
If you've spent years trying to fix yourself through self-improvement strategies but still feel disconnected, exhausted, or stuck in cycles of shame, relational therapy can offer something different.
Rather than focusing on self-optimization, therapy with our team at Kindman & Co. creates space to understand your experiences in context, reconnect with your emotions and body, and explore who you are beyond productivity, performance, or self-improvement.
Learn more about working with a therapist at Kindman & Co. →
Featured therapist author:
Liam DeGeorgio, AMFT, is a neurodivergent associate marriage & family therapist who strives to challenge society’s expectations and perceptions of ‘normal’.
Liam lives with ADHD, OCD, and PTSD and enjoys working with clients wanting to challenge toxic masculinity, embrace feminism & anti-racism, and adults with childhood trauma. He loves playing the drums, reading books, and his four cats.
GET HELP NOW
If you are interested in therapy with Kindman & Co. and would like to learn more about the services we have to help you, follow these quick & easy steps:
Schedule a free 20-minute phone consultation with our Care Coordinator.
Get matched with the therapist who’s right for you.
Start feeling more supported and fulfilled in your life and relationships!
THERAPY AT KINDMAN & CO.
We are here for your diverse L.A. counseling needs. Our team of therapists provides lgbtqia+ affirmative therapy, couples therapy & premarital counseling, grief & loss counseling, group therapy, and more. We have specialists in trauma, women's issues, depression & anxiety, substance use, mindfulness & embodiment, and support for creatives.
We look forward to welcoming you for therapy in Highland Park and online.
